Review of Research on Tooth Surface Error Control of Large CNC Gear Form Grinding

Zhiwei Chen; Shuang Ding; Zhanqun Song; Zhongyu Wang

doi:10.16578/j.issn.1004.2539.2022.04.003

您当前的位置：

首页 >

文章列表页 >

Review of Research on Tooth Surface Error Control of Large CNC Gear Form Grinding

Review | 更新时间：2022-09-25

- Review of Research on Tooth Surface Error Control of Large CNC Gear Form Grinding
- Journal of Mechanical Transmission Vol. 46, Issue 4, Pages: 22-30(2022)
- 作者机构：
  
  1.扬州大学机械工程学院，江苏扬州 225127
- 作者简介：
- 基金信息：
- DOI：10.16578/j.issn.1004.2539.2022.04.003
  CLC：
扫描看全文
陈志炜,丁爽,宋占群等.大型数控成形磨齿齿面误差控制研究综述[J].机械传动,2022,46(04):22-30.

Chen Zhiwei,Ding Shuang,Song Zhanqun,et al.Review of Research on Tooth Surface Error Control of Large CNC Gear Form Grinding[J].Journal of Mechanical Transmission,2022,46(04):22-30.
陈志炜,丁爽,宋占群等.大型数控成形磨齿齿面误差控制研究综述[J].机械传动,2022,46(04):22-30. DOI： 10.16578/j.issn.1004.2539.2022.04.003.

Chen Zhiwei,Ding Shuang,Song Zhanqun,et al.Review of Research on Tooth Surface Error Control of Large CNC Gear Form Grinding[J].Journal of Mechanical Transmission,2022,46(04):22-30. DOI： 10.16578/j.issn.1004.2539.2022.04.003.

摘要

相比于蜗杆砂轮磨齿，成形磨齿适用于大直径大模数齿轮的高效磨削，但也存在磨削精度控制难、精密修形难、在机精密检测难等问题。综述成形磨齿齿面误差控制方面的国内外研究和发展，从砂轮修整系统误差、齿轮磨削系统误差以及在机检测系统误差3个误差源方面对近些年国内外研究成果和存在的问题展开讨论，提出了需要进一步深入研究的方向和内容：构建“砂轮修整-成形磨削-齿面误差在机评估-机床误差逆向溯源-误差跟踪补偿”的闭环磨削系统，实现磨削精度、修形精度的提高；开展齿面误差映射建模、齿面误差在机评估和齿面误差跟踪修正方法研究，优化在机检测和补偿系统。掌握成形磨削误差补偿方面的研究和发展现状，有利于在高精密成形磨齿以及齿轮检测装备的研制过程中实现关键技术突破。

Abstract

Compared with the worm wheel gear grinding，gear form grinding is suitable for high efficiency grinding of large diameter and large modulus gears，despite difficulties concerning with grinding precision control，precise modification of tooth profile and precision detection in machine. Reviewing the research and development of gear form grinding tooth surface error control at home and abroad， the research achievements and existing problems at home and abroad in recent years from the three error sources which are the grinding wheel dressing system error，gear grinding system error and on-machine inspection system error are discussed， proposes directions and contents that need further research which are the construction of a closed-loop grinding system of “grinding wheel dressing，gear form grinding，on-machine evaluation of tooth surface error，reverse traceability of machine tool errors & error tracking compensation” and the realization of the improvement of grinding accuracy and dressing accuracy，carries out research on tooth surface error mapping modeling，tooth surface error on-machine evaluation and tooth surface error tracking correction method，and optimizes the on-machine inspection and compensation system. Being familiar with the research and development status of gear form grinding error compensation is beneficial to key technology breakthroughs in the development of high precision gear form grinding and gear testing equipment.

关键词

成形磨齿齿面误差砂轮修整系统齿面修形在机检测误差控制

Keywords

Gear form grindingTooth surface errorGrinding wheel dressing systemTooth surface modificationOn-machine inspectionError control

references

闵好年，周玉山，邵明.渐开线齿轮模具成形磨削砂轮廓形的计算通式［J］.现代制造工程，2006（1）：1-3.

MIN Haonian，ZHOU Yushan，SHAO Ming.The calculation of grinding sand profile for involute gear mould forming［J］.Modern Manufacturing Engineering，2006（1）：1-3.

ISHIBASHI A，YOSHINO H.Design and manufacture of gear cutting tools and gears with an arbitrary profile：a method for calculating grinding wheel-profile for hob finishing［J］.JSME International Journal，1989，32（1）：124-130.

WU Y R，FENG Z H，ZHANG Z X.Simulation of a cylindrical form grinding process by the radial-ray shooting（RRS）method［J］.Mechanism and Machine Theory，2009，45（2）：261-272.

何坤，李国龙，蒋林，等.基于数字法的成形砂轮廓形计算及包络面仿真［J］.机械工程学报，2018，54（1）：205-213.

HE Kun，LI Guolong，JIANG Lin，et al.The calculation of forming sand profile and the simulation of enveloping surface based on digital method［J］.Journal of Mechanical Engineering，2018，54（1）：205-213.

何坤，李国龙，杜彦斌，等.基于多轴附加运动优化的成形磨削修形齿面扭曲消减方法［J］.计算机集成制造系统，2019，25（8）：1946-1955.

HE Kun，LI Guolong，DU Yanbin，et al.Tooth surface distortion reduction method based on multi-axis additional motion optimization［J］.Computer Integrated Manufacturing System，2019，25（8）：1946-1955.

秦大同，朱晓冬，刘向阳.修形斜齿轮成形磨削中的砂轮廓形优化方法和齿形误差分析［J］.机械传动，2013，37（4）：1-5.

QIN Datong，ZHU Xiaodong，LIU Xiangyang.Sand profile optimization method and tooth profile error analysis in profile grinding of modified helical gears［J］.Journal of Mechanical Transmission，2013，37（4）：1-5.

李国龙，李先广，刘飞，等.拓扑修形齿轮附加径向运动成形磨削中的砂轮廓形优化方法［J］.机械工程学报，2011，47（11）：155-162.

LI Guolong，LI Xianguang，LIU Fei，et al.Sand profile optimization method in topological modification gear with radial motion forming grinding［J］.Journal of Mechanical Engineering，2011，47（11）：155-162.

康权.成形磨削砂轮修整精密检测补偿技术研究［D］.重庆：重庆大学，2013：31-45.

KANG Quan.Research on the precision detection and compensation technology for the dressing of forming grinding wheels［D］.Chongqing：Chongqing University，2013：31-45.

SALJE E，MACKENSEN H G.Dressing of conventional and CBN grinding wheels with diamond form rollers［J］.Elsevier，1984，33（1）：205-209.

张四弟，左键民，张兆祥，等.成形砂轮高精度修整技术研究［J］.机床与液压，2011，39（17）：39-41.

ZHANG Sidi，ZUO Jianmin，ZHANG Zhaoxiang，et al.Research on high-precision dressing technology of forming grinding wheels［J］.Machine Tool and Hydraulics，2011，39（17）：39-41.

宋晓，刘丰林，徐晓刚，等.新型数控砂轮修整系统的研制［J］.机械科学与技术，2012，31（10）：1634-1637.

SONG Xiao，LIU Fenglin，XU Xiaogang，et al.Development of a new CNC grinding wheel dressing system［J］.Mechanical Science and Technology for Aerospace Engineering，2012，31（10）：1634-1637.

张虎.数控成形磨削齿面误差理论与修正方法研究［D］.南京：南京工业大学，2014：45-56.

ZHANG Hu.Research on error theory and correction method of CNC forming Gginding tooth surface［D］.Nanjing：Nanjing University of Technology，2014：45-56.

苏建新，邓效忠，任小中，等.斜齿轮成形磨削砂轮修形与仿真［J］.农业机械学报，2010，41（10）：219-222.

SU Jianxin，DENG Xiaozhong，REN Xiaozhong，et al.Forming grinding wheel modification and simulation of helical gears［J］.Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Machinery，2010，41（10）：219-222.

张虎，黄筱调，方成刚，等.砂轮修整误差对数控成形磨齿加工精度的影响［J］.南京工业大学学报（自然科学版），2013，35（4）：26-32.

ZHANG Hu，HUANG Xiaotiao，FANG Chenggang，et al.The influence of grinding wheel dressing error on the precision of CNC forming gear grinding［J］.Journal of Nanjing University of Technology（Natural Science Edition），2013，35（4）：26-32.

ESMAEILI S M，MAYER J R R，SANDERS M P，et al.Five-axis machine tool volumetric and geometric error reduction by indirect geometric calibration and lookup tables［J］.Journal of Manufacturing Science and Engineering，2021，143（7）：1-25.

DING S，WU W W，HUANG X D，et al.Single-axis driven measurement method to identify position-dependent geometric errors of a rotary table using double ball bar［J］.Springer London，2019，101（5）：1715-1724.

郭世杰，梅雪松，姜歌东.基于平面光栅的机床几何误差测量与辨识［J］.计算机集成制造系统，2020，26（8）：2037-2049.

GUO Shijie，MEI Xuesong，JIANG Gedong.Measurement and identification of machine tool geometric errors based on plane grating［J］.Computer Integrated Manufacturing Systems，2020，26（8）：2037-2049.

LIU C H，JYWE W Y，JAGER G，et al.The application of the dual-beam laser interferometer for calibration precision machine tools［J］.Technisches Messen：Sensoren，Gerate，Systeme，2009，76（5）：245-247.

ZHOU B C，WANG S L，FANG C C，et al.Geometric error modeling and compensation for five-axis CNC gear profile grinding machine tools［J］.The International Journal Advanced Manufacturing Technology，2017，92（5/6/7/8）：2639-2652.

XIA C J，WANG S L，SUN S L，et al.An identification method for crucial geometric errors of gear form grinding machine tools based on tooth surface posture error model［J］.Mechanism and Machine Theory，2018，138：76-94.

夏长久，王时龙，孙守利，等.五轴数控成形磨齿机几何误差—齿面误差模型及关键误差识别［J］.计算机集成制造系统，2020，26（5）：1191-1201.

XIA Changjiu，WANG Shilong，SUN Shouli，et al.Geometric error of five-axis CNC gear grinding machine-tooth surface error model and key error identification［J］.Computer Integrated Manufacturing System，2020，26（5）：1191-1201.

FU G Q，TAO C，XIE Y P，et al.Temperature-sensitive point selection for thermal error modeling of machine tool spindle by considering heat source regions［J］.The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology，2021，112（9/10）：1-14.

XIAO Q J，LUO Z H，LUO M，et al.Thermal deformation test and modeling of main spindle of numerical control vertical machining center［J］.Journal of Physics：Conference Series，2020，1583（1）：1-6.

LI Y，SHI H X，JI S J，et al.Thermal positioning error modeling of servo axis based on empirical modeling method［J］.Micromachines，2021，12（2）：1-22.

YUE H T，GUO C G，LI Q，et al.Thermal error modeling of CNC milling machine tool spindle system in load machining：based on optimal specific cutting energy［J］.Journal of the Brazilian Society of Mechanical Sciences and Engineering，2020，42（9）：1235-1256.

KATAGERI P，SURESH B S，PASHA T A.An approach to identify and select optimal temperature-sensitive measuring points for thermal error compensation modeling in CNC machines：a case study using cantilever beam［J］.Materials Today：Proceedings，2021，45（1）：264-269.

周宝仓，王时龙，方成刚，等.大型数控成形磨齿机热误差建模及补偿［J］.中南大学学报（自然科学版），2017，48（10）：2672-2677.

ZHOU Baocang，WANG Shilong，FANG Chenggang，et al.Thermal error modeling and compensation of large-scale CNC forming gear grinding machine［J］.Journal of Central South University（Natural Science Edition），2017，48（10）：2672-2677.

方成刚，葛海燕，洪荣晶.砂轮偏心对单侧成形磨齿齿形误差的影响分析［J］.计算机集成制造系统，2012，18（11）：2509-2514.

FANG Chenggang，GE Haiyan，HONG Rongjing.Analysis of the influence of the eccentricity of the grinding wheel on the tooth profile error of the unilateral profile grinding［J］.Computer Integrated Manufacturing System，2012，18（11）：2509-2514.

方成刚，巩建鸣，郭二廓，等.圆柱齿轮偏心对成形磨齿精度的影响及补偿［J］.计算机集成制造系统，2015，21（3）：716-723.

FANG Chenggang，GONG Jianming，GUO Erkuo，et al.The influence and compensation of cylindrical gear eccentricity on the precision of forming and grinding teeth［J］.Computer Integrated Manufacturing System，2015，21（3）：716-723.

YOSHINO H，IKENO K.Tooth-trace crowning in form grinding of helical gears.［J］.Transactions of the Japan Society of Mechanical Engineers，1991，57（538）：2144-2148.

KOBAYASHI Y，NISHIDA N，OUGIYA Y，et al.Tooth trace modification processing of helix gear by form grinding method［J］.Transactions of the Japan Society of Mechanical Engineers C，1995，61（590）：4088-4093.

郭二廓，黄筱调，袁鸿，等.基于提高成形磨削效率和精度的接触线优化［J］.计算机集成制造系统，2013，19（1）：67-74.

GUO Erkuo，HUANG Xiaotiao，YUAN Hong，et al.Contact line optimization based on improving the efficiency and precision of forming grinding［J］.Computer Integrated Manufacturing System，2013，19（1）：67-74.

任永强，杨建国.五轴数控机床综合误差补偿解耦研究［J］.机械工程学报，2004，40（2）：55-59.

REN Yongqiang，YANG Jianguo.Research on decoupling of comprehensive error compensation for five-axis CNC machine tools［J］.Journal of Mechanical Engineering，2004，40（2）：55-59.

HSU Y Y，WANG S S.A new compensation method for geometry errors of five-axis machine tools［J］.International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture：Design，Research and Application，2007，47（2）：352-360.

陈剑雄，林述温.基于微分变换的多轴数控机床几何误差解耦研究［J］.中国机械工程，2014，25（17）：2290-2294.

CHEN Jianxiong，LIN Shuwen.Research on geometric error decoupling of multi-axis CNC machine tools based on differential transformation［J］.China Mechanical Engineering，2014，25（17）：2290-2294.

廖琳.数控蜗杆砂轮磨齿机空间误差解耦补偿研究［D］.重庆：重庆大学，2017：39-52.

LIAO Lin.Research on decoupling compensation of spatial errors of CNC worm gear grinding machine［D］.Chongqing：Chongqing University，2017：39-52.

DING S，HUANG X D，YU C J，et al.Actual inverse kinematics for position-independent and position-dependent geometric error compensation of five-axis machine tools［J］.International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture，2016，111：55-62.

XIA C J，WANG S L，WANG S B，et al.Geometric error identification and compensation for rotary worktable of gear profile grinding machines based on single-axis motion measurement and actual inverse kinematic model［J］.Mechanism and Machine Theory，2021，155：1-20.

TIAN W J，GAO W G，CHANG W F，et al.Error modeling and sensitivity analysis of a five-axis machine tool［J］.Mathematical Problems in Engineering，2014：2037-2051.

CHENG Q，FENG Q N，LIU Z F，et al.Sensitivity analysis of machining accuracy of multi-axis machine tool based on POE screw theory and morris method［J］.The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology，2016，84（9/10/11/12）：2301-2318.

高峰，李艳，黄玉美，等.数控齿轮加工机床的在机测量系统［J］.机械科学与技术，2008（10）：1225-1227.

GAO Feng，LI Yan，HUANG Yumei，et al.On-machine measurement system of CNC gear processing machine tool［J］.Mechanical Science and Technology，2008（10）：1225-1227.

范宜艳，赵斌，马国鹭.基于光学标靶与测距仪的隐藏区域坐标测量［J］.激光技术，2014，38（6）：723-728.

FAN Yiyan，ZHAO Bin，MA Guolu.Coordinate measurement of hidden area based on optical target and rangefinder［J］.Laser Technology，2014，38（6）：723-728.

汪中厚，曹欢，李刚，等.基于成形磨齿机的测头径向误差补偿［J］.机械传动，2017，41（3）：143-146.

WANG Zhonghou，CAO Huan，LI Gang，et al.Radial error compensation of probe based on profile grinding machine［J］.Journal of Mechanical Transmission，2017，41（3）：143-146.

吴彬彬，黄筱调，方成刚，等.数控成形磨齿机在线测量系统标定误差的辨识及补偿［J］.组合机床与自动化加工技术，2015（6）：74-77.

WU Binbin，HUANG Xiaotiao，FANG Chenggang，et al.Identification and compensation of calibration error of online measurement system of CNC forming gear grinding machine［J］.Modular Machine Tool and Automatic Processing Technology，2015（6）：74-77.

孙奇楠，汪中厚，马雅鹤，等.成形磨齿机在线测量探头预行程误差研究及补偿［J］.陕西理工大学学报（自然科学版），2019，35（2）：17-21.

SUN Qi'nan，WANG Zhonghou，MA Yahe，et al.Research and compensation of the pre-stroke error of the online measuring probe of the profile grinding machine［J］.Journal of Shaanxi University of Technology（Natural Science Edition），2019，35（2）：17-21.

杨灵敏，李小宁，李光华.基于曲率自适应测量的齿形误差在线测量技术研究［J］.机床与液压，2014，42（19）：50-53.

YANG Lingmin，LI Xiaoning，LI Guanghua.Research on online measurement technology of tooth profile error based on curvature adaptive measurement［J］.Machine Tool and Hydraulics，2014，42（19）：50-53.

王伟，李晴朝，康文俊，等.基于综合评价体系的五轴数控机床加工性能评价和误差溯源方法［J］.机械工程学报，2017，53（21）：149-157.

WANG Wei，LI Qingchao，KANG Wenjun，et al.Five-axis CNC machine tool processing performance evaluation and error traceability method based on comprehensive evaluation system［J］.Journal of Mechanical Engineering，2017，53（21）：149-157.

唐宇航，范晋伟，陈东菊，等.基于蒙特卡洛模拟的机床关键几何误差溯源方法［J］.北京工业大学学报，2017，43（11）：1619-1628.

TANG Yuhang，FAN Jinwei，CHEN Dongju，et al.A method for tracing key geometric errors of machine tools based on Monte Carlo simulation［J］.Journal of Beijing University of Technology，2017，43（11）：1619-1628.

钟学敏.考虑误差耦合的数控机床空间误差建模、辨识及多层误差溯源研究［D］.武汉：华中科技大学，2019：64-94.

ZHONG Xuemin.Research on spatial error modeling，identification and multi-level error traceability of CNC machine tools considering error coupling［D］.Wuhan：Huazhong University of Science and Technology，2019：64-94.

陈燕，殷国富，陈永洪.平面齿内齿轮包络鼓形蜗杆齿面误差检测及溯源［J］.四川大学学报（工程科学版），2016，48（3）：171-177.

CHEN Yan，YIN Guofu，CHEN Yonghong.Detection and traceability of tooth surface errors of drum worm with plane-tooth internal gears［J］.Journal of Sichuan University（Engineering Science Edition），2016，48（3）：171-177.

Views

下载量

CSCD

Alert me when the article has been cited

提交

Tools

Publicity Resources

Influence of Assembly Errors and Tooth Surface Modification on Transmission Errors of Curvilinear Cylindrical Gears

Accurate Calculation of the Maximum Grinding Wheel Diameter for the Form Grinding of Modification Herringbone Gears

Multi-objective Orthogonal Test Simulation and Modification Parameter Design based on Ease-off Topology

Research of Measurement Technology of 3D Tooth Surface Error of Non-circular Gear

Design of Spiral Bevel Gear Tooth Surface Topology

Related Author

No data

Related Institution

School of Intelligent Manufacturing, Panzhihua University

The Research Institute of CSIC

School of Mechanical & Electronic Engineering， Henan University of Science & Technology

School of Mechanical & Electronical Engineering， Lanzhou University of Technology

Jiangxi JMCG Axle Gear Co.， Ltd.

⁰